Richard Lovelady had a split series, standing out in one game but suffering in another. In the second game, he performed well, striking out Nick Gonzales with runners on the corners and getting the win. However, in the third game, he gave up runs, including an RBI single that gave the Pirates the lead. His performance in the second game saved him from a lower grade, but losing the lead in a series finale is not easily forgotten.
Game 3 was the problem. He gave up 4 hits and 3 runs in 2 innings, including the RBI single by Henry Davis that put Pittsburgh ahead for good. The win in Game 2 saves him from a failing grade, but surrendering the lead in a series finale in extras is not something that gets forgotten quickly.