The possible appointment of Carrick as permanent manager has sparked debate among football figures. While some, like Gary Neville and Roy Keane, have expressed doubts about his ability to take on the role permanently, others, such as Michael Owen and Wayne Rooney, have expressed their unconditional support. Owen, speaking to the Manchester Evening News, via Casino.org, was surprised by the doubts about Carrick's continuity, highlighting the team's good performance under his direction.

“Why on Earth is this even a question? I don’t get it. I’m astounded by certain people saying ‘No, no, no, they shouldn’t appoint him’,” Owen commented. Rooney, for his part, did not hesitate to affirm that Carrick should be appointed manager permanently, highlighting his knowledge of the club and his ability to connect with the players.
Rooney stated, “100% he should [get the job]. I have said this. I knew this was going to happen with Michael Carrick. I know his character, his personality very well. It needed a calm head, but someone who knew the place and that the players needed some love, and he has given them that.”
Carrick, meanwhile, has been able to focus on the Premier League, as the team did not participate in European competitions or national cups. The team will not play again until April 13 at home against Leeds United, as the FA Cup quarter-finals will be played next weekend.